Legal and compliance requirements for personal property appraisers

While real estate appraisers are subject to extensive state licensing and federal regulations, the legal and compliance landscape for personal property appraisers is less formalized. However, to be a credible and ethical personal property appraiser, adherence to specific standards and best practices is essential.

Here are the key legal and compliance requirements and standards that personal property appraisers should meet:

1. Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP)

• The Cornerstone: USPAP is the most critical standard for personal property appraisers. It’s a set of ethical and performance standards developed by The Appraisal Foundation (TAF), authorized by Congress as the source of appraisal standards and qualifications.
• What it Covers: USPAP dictates how appraisals should be developed and reported, ensuring impartiality, objectivity, and independence. It includes:
  • Ethics Rule: Mandates integrity, impartiality, objectivity, and independent judgment. It prohibits misleading or fraudulent practices and requires confidentiality.
  • Competency Rule: Requires an appraiser to have the knowledge and experience to complete an assignment competently. If not, they must disclose it and gain the necessary competency or decline the assignment.
  • Scope of Work Rule: Defines the extent of research and analysis required for a credible appraisal. It ensures the appraiser and client agree on the purpose, intended users, and type of value being sought.
  • Jurisdictional Exception Rule: Addresses situations where local laws or regulations might supersede USPAP, requiring the appraiser to comply with the stricter standard.
  • Record Keeping Rule: Mandates appraisers maintain detailed workfiles for a specific period (typically five years after preparation or two years after final disposition of any litigation, whichever is longer).
  • Standards Rules 7 & 8 (Personal Property): These are specifically dedicated to personal property.
    • Standard 7 (Development): Details the requirements for developing a credible personal property appraisal, including identifying the client and intended use, defining the property, conducting market analysis, and applying appropriate valuation methods (e.g., Sales Comparison, Cost Approach).
    • Standard 8 (Reporting): Outlines the requirements for communicating personal property appraisal results clearly, accurately, and non-misleadingly. This includes specific elements for appraisal reports (such as property description, purpose, value conclusion, effective date, limiting conditions, and appraiser’s certification).
• Training and Updates: Personal property appraisers are generally required to take a 15-hour USPAP course initially and then a 7-hour USPAP update course every two years to stay current. These courses must be taught by Appraiser Qualifications Board (AQB) Certified Instructors.
  

  2. Professional Organization Standards and Ethics

• Self-Regulation: In the absence of direct state licensing, professional appraisal organizations play a crucial role in setting and enforcing ethical and competency standards for their members.
• Key Organizations:
  • American Society of Appraisers (ASA): Has a comprehensive code of ethics and specific “Principles of Valuation” courses. Members must adhere to strict requirements for education, experience, and report review to achieve and maintain accreditations (AM, ASA).
  • International Society of Appraisers (ISA): Also has a rigorous code of ethics and requires its members to complete its Core Course in Appraisal Studies and ongoing continuing education.
  • Appraisers Association of America (AAA): Emphasizes ethical conduct and professional competence, particularly in fine and decorative arts.
• Membership Benefits: Beyond demonstrating commitment to standards, membership in these organizations often includes access to continuing education, professional development, peer review, and a mechanism for client complaints if an appraiser violates their ethical code.

3. Federal Regulations (IRS, FIRREA)

• IRS Requirements for Charitable Contributions: When personal property is donated to a qualified charity and the value exceeds certain thresholds (e.g., $5,000), the IRS requires a “qualified appraisal” from a “qualified appraiser.” The IRS provides specific definitions for both. While not a license, failing to meet these can result in penalties for the taxpayer and the appraiser.
  • A “qualified appraiser” must hold themselves out to the public as an appraiser, be qualified to appraise the type of property, and understand the substantiation requirements for non-cash contributions. They cannot be the donor, recipient, or related parties.
  • A “qualified appraisal” must be prepared in accordance with generally accepted appraisal standards (like USPAP), be for a “qualified use,” and include specific information.
• FIRREA (Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989): While FIRREA primarily focuses on real estate appraisal in federally related transactions, its Title XI does influence personal property appraisals, particularly when they are collateral for loans from federally regulated financial institutions or involve government assets. In such cases, appraisers must meet specific certification and licensing standards as mandated by FIRREA.

4. State Laws (Limited, but Important)

• No Universal Licensing: Unlike real estate appraisers, there is generally no state-level licensing specifically for personal property appraisers in the United States.
• Specific Contexts: However, some states might have specific regulations or requirements in certain contexts, such as:
  • Probate or Estate Administration: Courts may have preferences or requirements for appraisers involved in valuing assets for estates.
  • Expert Witness Testimony: If an appraiser serves as an expert witness in a legal dispute, they must meet the court’s standards for expertise and credibility.
  • Consumer Protection Laws: General consumer protection laws apply, meaning appraisers must act honestly, disclose potential conflicts of interest, and avoid deceptive practices.

5. Contractual and Ethical Obligations

• Client Agreements: Appraisers must have clear written agreements with their clients that define the scope of work, intended use of the appraisal, type of value, fees, and any limiting conditions or assumptions.
• Confidentiality: Appraisers are ethically and often legally bound to maintain client confidentiality, only disclosing information as required by law or with client permission.
• Due Diligence: A personal property appraiser must conduct thorough research, identify and analyze relevant data, and apply appropriate methodologies to arrive at a credible value conclusion. This includes examining the physical characteristics, provenance, market conditions, and any legal or economic factors affecting the property’s value.
• Impartiality: Appraisers must remain objective and unbiased, regardless of the client or the desired outcome. Their compensation should not be contingent on a predetermined value

In summary, while state licensing for personal property appraisers is rare, the most significant compliance requirements revolve around adhering to USPAP and the ethical and professional standards set by reputable professional appraisal organizations. Meeting these standards is crucial for an appraiser’s credibility, defensibility of their reports, and ability to serve clients effectively, especially in legal and financial contexts.

Collectorpro Software is a leader in providing technology and services to many industries including Personal Property Appraisers.  Find out more here.